An Overview of Off-Market Property Sales in Real Estate

In various markets the topic of off-market real estate is in the news. For the student of real estate, off-market real estate transactions are excellent working example that help to highlight some of the lesser-known players in a given real estate market, and expose some tricks of the trade used by the most experienced professionals in the real estate community – many of which, by the way, prefer off-market deals.

QUESTION: What is Off-Market Real Estate?

Off-market real estate transactions occur when real estate is sold by a seller to a buyer without ever making the sale of the property widely known to the general public. Sometimes called “pocket listings,” “private exclusive listings” “quiet listings,” or “off-MLS listings,” these are private sales of real property, often between experienced insiders in the real estate community. The sales may or may not involve agents or brokers, but are often specifically enabled as one broker creates the sale between a buyer and a seller. That broker may end up “double-ending” a real estate transaction (although not always), and end up capturing a commission from both the buyer and the seller – that practice is often called “dual agency” in property sales.

Regardless of the name, off-market real estate sales are common, and are beneficial to many buyers and sellers.

There are stakeholders that are discouraging or resentful of off-market sale of real property, and there have been some attempts to ban pocket-listings, or even to make private sales of real estate illegal. The practice itself is amoral; neither good nor bad, off-market sales are simply a form of transaction. And while both hazards and benefits exist in these deals, any liability or benefit from an off-market transaction depends on the experience of the players and the context of the particular deal.

History of Off-Market Real Estate Transaction

As long as there has been property, there have been exchanges of property. The earliest exchanges of property were most likely traded between the buyer and seller directly, likely did not have “agents” to facilitate the transaction; those sales did not have an established market where the sales itself could be formally announced. Historically, most real estate transactions were “off-market.”

Baked into the framing of the idea of an “off-market” sale is the assumption of public market. If a distinction needs to be made, it is probably more historically accurate to say there are real estate sales, and sometimes “on market” sales. The presumption by some stakeholders that all real estate for sale is, or should be, listed in some public market is entirely modern.

The Role of Relationships in Off-Market Property Sales

A defining feature of many off-market sales of real property is the role of relationships between experienced members of a local real estate community.

Very often, the best properties are well known to the local players. There may be open offers to buy those properties, or when a property could be sold, an experienced buyer is easy to find from within the personal connections of the local investors and real estate companies. The general public is not involved in those sales, because a fair price can be found within the networks and relationships of the insiders; advertising the property in public markets is not necessary or desirable for those parties.

Personal knowledge of desirable off-market property, or personal connections that make it possible to be invited to buy a valuable local property, are the end results of both experience, a network of professional relationships, and a good reputation amongst other local real estate professionals.

“On-Market” Listings of Real Estate

In a given community, a typical public market for the sale of real estate might be a multiple-listing service (MLS).

Some leaders in the MLS community see their role as helping agents and clients. The MLSs in some cases become the clearing house for some large percentage of property sale details in a community, and disperse those details via internet data exchange (IDX) to online property portals, to the various websites of real estate companies, or to proptech companies.

In some cases, the MLSs would like to to insist that all transactions are included in their listings, in the name of “transparency.” MLSs are generally hostile to the idea of off-market transactions, and have been vocal about insisting that all available property, including off-market or “exclusive” sales, be recorded on the MLS systems. The voices of MLS interest have been clear in the recent National Association of Realtor® announcements about “Clear Cooperation” with respect to off-market deals. While it is easy to see how MLS bodies might want to be make themselves central, it’s not altogether clear why details about the private sale of private property should be required to be public.

While public markets, or lists of available property for sale, can often improve efficiency in the market or offer other benefits, forced participation and the effective elimination of off-market property sales is not clearly beneficial when existing buyers and sellers are happy with the terms of their deals.

Stakeholders in Off-Market Transactions

There are various stakeholders, or would-be stakeholders, in off-market real estate sales:

* Sellers of Real Estate
* Buyer of Real Estate
* Real Estate Agents
* Real Estate Brokerages
* The Cash-for-homes Real Estate Companies
* Multiple-Listing Services
* Technology Companies
* Industry Groups, Government Regulators, Advocates

Let’s look at each stakeholder and some of the benefits and drawbacks that befall the stakeholders in off-market real estate opportunities.

Off-Market Real Estate for Sellers

Of all the stakeholders in a potential real estate deal, the seller is the most essential. It is the seller (and perhaps their agent) that has the authority as to whether a real estate deal will be sold within the seller’s network of relationships, or if the property is to be put on the open market, and perhaps widely marketed and advertised.

Q: Are off-market real estate deals good for sellers?

For many sellers, yes. While agents can have strong incentives in off-market sales, these sales are the historical norm, and a popular choice of sellers based on a variety of benefits.

There is a long list of reasons why some sellers choose to sell their property from within a private network as opposed to providing wide, public exposure to the property sale. Many sellers prefer off-market transactions because they are faster and easier than formal transactions. Classically, privacy is a strong example of why some sellers sell off-market. In a similar vein, some sellers sell off-market out of shame or avoidance; the property is distressed, and the seller doesn’t want to draw attention to the mess, or doesn’t want the transaction to become known to neighbors or other parties. Other sellers (and buyers) want to keep the sales history out of the public eye – in many markets, the sales price for a given property is never made public (there are 12 states in the United States where the sale price for a property is not a part of the public record). Because public reductions in sales price can hurt negotiations for sellers, some sellers use off-market as a way to test the sales price; if they reduce the price off-market, most buyers are unaware of the reduction.

The risk for sellers in private, off-market sales is a lower price, a longer sales cycle (although off-market sales are often faster), or less-desirable terms. When a seller has the luxury of time, and has the resources to prepare a property for sale, they can often achieve a better price, and better terms, when information about the sale is widely distributed, and many buyers have the opportunity to make an offer, to bid up the price, or to offer the seller other incentives to choose their offer in a given sale.

There is one main criticism of off-market deals as it pertains to sellers; when a seller agrees to allow their property to remain off the public market, their agent may sometimes “hide” the listing, to avoid having to cooperate with a buyer’s agent. That is a reality in some off-market transactions.

Off-Market Real Estate for Buyers

It is a simple fact that when off-market transactions exist, not all buyers will have the opportunity to make an offer or a bid on the property. It is also a fact that in every off-market transaction, there is both a buyer and seller that like the deal enough to come to an agreement. While some buyers miss out, other buyers benefit from private sales of real estate.

Q: Are off-market real estate deals good for buyers?

In many cases, yes. For a certain class of real estate buyer, off-market deals are actively pursued, and often preferred. In many markets, the best properties are traded between insiders, and to be a part of preferred deals, those buyers must embrace the insider-networking that provides access to off-market deals. Sometimes those properties are purchased in an absence of competition, at a below-market rate. In other cases, the buyer pays a competitive rate (or even pays above average), but gains access to deals that are desirable enough that a willing buyer is easy to come by. For very desirable properties, advertising the availability of the property is unnecessary, and buyers feel lucky to be have access.

The risk for buyers of off-market deals is that the sellers and agents that offer those properties, have little-to-no incentive to show the buyer alternative properties. If a buyer is playing in the off-market space, there is less information, less disclosure, properties are sometimes sold “as-is,” sometimes with no time for inspections. Off-market deals can be low-information, as the emphasis is on speed and convenience for the parties involved, less so on education or allowances for less-experienced buyers to navigate due diligence.

Off-Market Real Estate for Real Estate Agents

Real estate agents may be the greatest champions of off-market sales, as they benefit from higher commissions and elevated importance to buyers and sellers. The experience and exposure that is a part of the daily lives of real estate professionals make them “the insiders” that initiate or are invited to participate in these deals.

Q: Are off-market sales good for real estate agents?

When an agent has a property listed, they may already have a known-buyer in mind, or may immediately begin to share the availability of that property with their connections. If the property sells, it stands that the agent should earn a commission. In off-market sales, if that same agent can also find a willing buyer, that agent may collect a commission from both sides – “double-ending” the sale. The potential to double-end the commission can make off-market deals especially attractive to some agents, and may in some instances benefit the agent more than the buyer or seller.

There is nothing corrupt about “brokering” a deal between a buyer and a seller. In some cases, the special needs of the seller can be arranged for off-market, with the seller just waiting until the agent finds the right buyer, and the sale can happen immediately, with no announcement at all that the property was for sale. In other cases, there can be a conflict of interest, as the agent intentionally keeps the listing private, which can delay the sale, and/or that agent pushes a sale on a buyer when other properties might have been more suitable for that buyer’s needs.

Some agents – particularly buyer’s agents – can lose in off-market sales as the seller’s agent may resist cooperation, because they don’t want to share the commission. It is a somewhat common practice for a selling agent to ignore communication, or to falsely imply the property isn’t available, in order to discourage another agent from bringing in a buyer where the commission would have to be shared.

Off-Market Real Estate for Real Estate Brokerages

Real Estate brokers and real estate companies often benefit from pocket listings and off-market listings, as valuable property in the community is communicated among the best clients within that brokerage.

Q: Are off-market sales good for real estate brokerages?

Yes, they may be especially good for brokerages, or real estate companies that employ several agents.

Off-market real estate transactions can be good for real estate companies and brokerages. Real estate companies benefit from being able to represent the seller’s listing. In an off-market listing, the real estate brokerage very often will take a property they represent for the seller, and then privately share the availability of that sale exclusively between the agents and brokers that work for that specific company, finding a buyer from within their own customer base. In these cases the brokerage may benefit from higher yield per property (a share of the commissions from both the buyer and the seller), as well as increased prestige for having “inside deals” or “private exclusive listings” to offer their customers.

Off-Market Sales and Cash for Homes Companies

Outside of traditional “retail” residential real estate are a surprisingly large number of companies that do all or most of their deals off-market, as they actively market to home owners, offering to buy those homes for cash.

Q: Do cash-for-homes companies benefit from off-market sales?

Most certainly they do.

“We buy your homes for cash” companies are common in the United States, and the model exists in other markets; there are cash for homes companies in Japan, in the UK, and other markets. In all cases, these companies offer to buy property in fast, convenient transactions – sometimes in under a week.

While the buyers and wholesalers involved in these businesses tend to be very experienced, the sellers can be under-educated, and in some cases sell their property for much less than market rates.

Off-Market Real Estate and Multiple Listing Services (MLSs)

The concepts of off-market real estate and cooperative multiple listing services (MLSs) are mostly incompatible. When a property listing is included in a MLS, it is mostly “on the market” in a public sense, and is no longer an “off-market” property.

Q: Do multiple-listing services like off-market property?

It is possible to imagine a world where the local/regional/national MLS organization could be in support of off-market real estate, or at least neutral on the topic. In reality, the voices coming from MLS leadership are generally hostile and accusatory when it comes to off-market real estate transactions.

“At its core, an MLS is a broker cooperative: an organization in which multiple competitive companies agree to abide by shared rules. This cooperation agreement empowers MLS participants to provide superior professional services and access to inventory for their clients.”
— Sam DeBord, from RealEstateNews.com

MLS bodies consistently lobby to have all inventory in a community listed in their databases. The MLS will insist that their role in keeping records of “all” transactions creates “transparency,” and helps with the creation of accurate statistics, etc.

A preponderance of off-market real estate sales in a community threatens the role and the relevancy of MLS systems. Perhaps from a spirit of self-preservation, MLS rhetoric is fairly aggressive about off-market property, sometimes insisting that all transactions must be included in the MLS listings, even when the seller is not accepting public offers. Recent announcements from the National Association of Realtors® (NAR) show support for the idea of a mandatory role for the MLS services.

Off-Market Real Estate and Property Technology (PropTech) Companies

Increasingly, there are third-party real estate companies and technology business models that would like to be a part of that “public” market by using or offering public details about real estate sales in the community.

Many proptech real estate companies rely on data they receive (via internet data exchange or IDX) from the MLS services and other sources.

“[MLSs] have their data systems certified on RESO’s Data Dictionary and Web API standards, which allows their brokers to operate more efficiently in cross-market data partnerships and technology collaborations.”
— Sam DeBord, from RealEstateNews.com

When a real estate transaction is private, these third-party tools and services are excluded. Insofar as these companies would like to “disrupt” the relationship between clients and agents, there is some animosity there. Recently, the real estate company Zillow announced it would penalize a property that initially tried to sell off-market, denying that property exposure on the Zillow platform (at least as long as the initial agent that assisted in the off-market sale is still involved).

Real estate companies that require data from agents’ listings or other would-be public data are some of the loudest voices against the practice of off-market sales.

Q: Do new technology models in real estate facilitate off-market real estate sales?

The relationship between off-market real estate and technology companies focused on real estate is not strong, but does exist. Some companies have found a way to use technology to connect buyers and sellers that prefer, or benefit from, off-market transactions. House Cashin is an example of an off-market platform (in the cash for homes space), proving that some of these proptech models can support buyers and sellers in off-market deals.

Industry Groups, Government Regulators, Fair Housing Advocates

There are several other interested parties that would like to have a say in otherwise private transactions.

As previously mentioned, NAR is an example of a powerful force in US real estate that is actively working to discourage off-market transactions (which is surprising in some ways, as those efforts work against the interests of many of their members). And there can be regulatory offices or other advocates that would like to be able to dictate terms in an otherwise private sale between a buyer and a seller.

There are some arguments that off-market transactions are potentially discriminatory. While it is true that off-market deals are mostly exclusive, and only available to insiders, that is about the nature of local networking between specialized parties – not the broad discrimination against protected groups. While “insider trading” is illegal in public equities, the sale of private property need not be offered to “everyone.”

Broad Satisfaction in Off-Market Real Estate Deals

Off-market real estate transactions are historically common and remain a popular choice for how a real estate deal transacts.

The popularity of off-market deals is the best argument for why that style of transaction is worthy of consideration and respect. In each successful real estate deal, there is a buyer and seller. If there are many off-market deals (and there are), and those buyers and sellers are satisfied, and even prefer to trade off-market, the value to those buyers and sellers is clear.

If the buyer and the seller in an expressly private sale of real estate are happy, the opinions and interests of third parties seem irrelevant

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *